Isaiah Simmons is the best rookie on defense you are going to want to go after. While the top 2 guys are the rookies for Madden, there are still plenty of others who could become elite players with progression Mut 23 coins. Finding a 21 year old cornerback that's 93 speed and size ought to be a priority. Even though he comes in with a 76 overall rating, within 2-3 years he will be a 90 shutdown cornerback with top end speed. For the following 10+ seasons of your franchise you will not have to be concerned about one facet of the area.
Chase Young is a obvious pick here and will likely be among the guys to trade for. The #2 overall pick is the highest rated newcomer in Madden NFL 23 having an 80. He has strength, the size, and X-Factor development trait that will likely make him untouchable. That having been said, it does not hurt to put out a feeler to whoever has him on your franchise and see whether you're able to entice him. If you're good at developing players however, Chase Young might not be well worth the price tag you'd have to cover to get him on your team.
Now we are getting into the sleepers of this rookie class. The men you might have a shot of becoming without giving up. The real reason he will be wanted by you though is that he as 93 rate, 93 jump, 75 struck power, and is a perfect developmental player. Within 2-3 years you're able to advance him into a star free safety that flies all over the area. He must be cheap to get!
That is about as near a infant Calvin Johnson as you will ever see. Most competent GMs in your league will probably observe the worth of a player like this but since he only comes in at 70 overall, you might be able to fleece a seasoned member of your franchise into getting him. If he is trained by you spam him for a couple of seasons buy madden nfl 23 coins, he will turn into one of the funniest weapons in all of Madden NFL 23. This is one of these players where it makes sense. Whatever it costs to get him on will probably look like a huge deal in 2-3 years.